Charles Henry Doupe 1883-1887

William Gabriel Spencer 1888-1895

Edmund Augustus Angell 1896-1898

Percy George Hooke Robinson 1899-1904

Theodore Mount Peck 1905-1920

George Israel Browne 1920-1923

James Theodore Carney 1923-1932

Floyd Williams Tompkins 1933-1959

Otis Charles 1959-1969

Haig Joseph Nargesian 1969-1988

Robert Leslie Ficks III 1988-2007

A granite plaque listing the Rectors of St. John's hangs in the transept of the church. It was donated by Ken and Audrey Hecken in 2008.